Sherlock Holmes, the legendary detective created by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, is known for many traits—his keen intellect, his violin-playing, and his sharp powers of observation. We've written about his deerstalker hat here. But perhaps one of the most enduring images of Holmes is his iconic pipe, which he often smoked as he pondered his latest mystery. Holmes' pipe-smoking is so closely associated with his character that it has become a defining part of his identity. In this article, we explore the types of pipes Holmes smoked, the manufacturers associated with his preferred styles, the types of tobacco he favored, and even Dr. Watson’s own smoking preferences.
Types of Pipes Sherlock Holmes Smoked
The Calabash Pipe
The Calabash pipe, with its distinctive curved shape and large bowl, is one of the most iconic pipes associated with Sherlock Holmes, even though Conan Doyle’s original stories do not explicitly describe him using a Calabash. This association was largely created by early theatrical and film adaptations, where actors preferred the Calabash pipe for its unique look and comfortable hold. The Calabash’s design, often made from gourd with a meerschaum lining, allowed smoke to cool before reaching the mouth, resulting in a smooth smoking experience. With its unmistakable silhouette, the Calabash pipe became a symbol of Holmes’ thoughtful, contemplative nature.
The Churchwarden Pipe
The Churchwarden pipe, known for its long, elegant stem, is another type often associated with Holmes. This pipe style dates back several centuries and was popular in Victorian England, likely appealing to Holmes’ classic and understated tastes. The long stem cools the smoke before it reaches the smoker’s mouth, offering a smoother experience. This pipe style has been depicted in several illustrations and film adaptations of Holmes, enhancing his air of sophistication as he considers complex cases.
The Briar Pipe
Briar pipes, crafted from briarwood, are known for their durability and practicality, making them popular among pipe smokers of Holmes’ era. Briarwood is heat-resistant and resilient, and briar pipes became widely popular in the mid-19th century. Holmes’ no-nonsense personality would align well with the briar pipe’s simplicity and functionality, allowing him to focus on his investigations without distraction. Many readers imagine Holmes using a reliable briar pipe as a practical, everyday choice.
Notable Pipe Manufacturers and Their Connection to Sherlock Holmes
Meerschaum Pipes
Meerschaum pipes, made from a soft white mineral found in certain regions of Turkey, were highly prized for their smooth smoke and beautiful, often intricate carvings. In Victorian times, meerschaum pipes were popular and considered a luxury item. Holmes may well have chosen a meerschaum for special occasions or deep thought, as it was a popular choice for seasoned pipe smokers of his day.
Peterson of Dublin
Peterson pipes, known for their craftsmanship and distinctive shapes, were well-regarded in Victorian England. Peterson of Dublin became one of the premier brands for quality pipes, and their classic styles, with added touches like silver accents, would suit Holmes’ refined, but understated aesthetic. While Conan Doyle does not specify any brand in the stories, it’s possible that Holmes, a figure of his time, may have owned a Peterson pipe.
The Tobacco Sherlock Holmes Smoked
Black Shag Tobacco
In some of the stories, Holmes is known to smoke Black Shag tobacco. This tobacco blend is known for its rich, strong, and somewhat dark flavor profile, which suits Holmes’ complex, intense personality. Black Shag’s boldness and full body make it a fitting choice for a character who often pursues challenging mental feats while smoking thoughtfully.
Latakia Tobacco
Latakia, a smoky, intense blend originally from Syria and Cyprus, became popular among Victorian pipe smokers, and many fans imagine it as one of Holmes’ choices. Known for its deeply aromatic, almost leathery quality, Latakia would appeal to someone with an affinity for bold, distinctive flavors. Although not explicitly stated, Holmes’ character and taste may align well with this choice.
Plug Tobacco
Plug tobacco, a dense, compact form that required cutting before use, was popular during Holmes’ era, as it was easy to store and carry. Holmes is mentioned as cutting his plug tobacco on occasion, indicating he preferred this type. The density of plug tobacco meant a long-lasting smoke, ideal for the lengthy thought sessions Holmes enjoyed.
Dr. John Watson's Smoking Preferences
Pipe Smoking by Watson
Dr. John Watson, Holmes’ loyal friend and biographer, also enjoys smoking and occasionally joins Holmes in a pipe. This shared habit serves to strengthen their camaraderie, allowing them to reflect on cases together. Watson’s pipe of choice is likely a simpler, practical one, reflecting his down-to-earth nature compared to Holmes’ complex and sometimes eccentric character.
Cigar Smoking by Watson
In addition to pipes, Watson occasionally indulges in cigars. This preference is noted in several instances throughout the stories. While the specific type of cigar he preferred isn’t mentioned, cigars add another layer to Watson’s personality, contrasting with Holmes' tendency to stick to pipes. This variety highlights Watson’s role as a balanced, relatable character who provides a stable counterpoint to Holmes’ intense personality.
Other Smoking Habits of Sherlock Holmes
Cigar Use by Sherlock Holmes
While Sherlock Holmes is best known for his pipe-smoking, he is occasionally described smoking cigars. In a few stories, Holmes relaxes with a cigar, often after a successful resolution to a case. This change in choice suggests that Holmes might reserve cigars for times of satisfaction or celebration. Although the brand or type of cigars he preferred isn’t specified, Holmes likely enjoyed a well-made Cuban or British cigar, considering their popularity in Victorian England.
Cigarettes in the Holmes Series
Though rare, Holmes occasionally smokes cigarettes. This choice is unusual for him, as it lacks the ritual and contemplation associated with his pipe. Cigarettes may have been a quick option during times of stress or intense focus, reflecting a brief, impulsive side of Holmes’ otherwise meticulous personality.
The Role of Smoking in Sherlock Holmes' Character and Detective Work
Thoughtful Ritual of Smoking for Reflection
For Holmes, pipe-smoking is more than a pastime; it’s a ritual that aids his concentration and analytical process. Holmes is often described taking long puffs of his pipe while mulling over a difficult case, and his thoughtful expression with a pipe in hand has become iconic. This ritual creates a sense of calm that seems essential to his process, showing how smoking serves as both a personal habit and a professional tool.
Smoking as a Tool for Mood and Setting
Conan Doyle used smoking as a device to set the mood in his stories. The dense clouds of pipe smoke swirling around Holmes in Baker Street create a fitting atmosphere for a detective. It’s an image of mystery, intellectual focus, and intrigue, helping readers imagine Holmes in his element. The smoke-filled air serves as a literary tool that emphasizes Holmes’ thoughtfulness, adding to the allure and mystique of the character.
The Sidney Paget Illustration Connection
Sidney Paget, the renowned illustrator for Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's Sherlock Holmes stories, played an instrumental role in shaping the visual image of Sherlock Holmes, particularly with his depiction of Holmes’ pipe-smoking habit. Paget’s illustrations are iconic, not only for bringing Holmes to life visually but for popularizing specific details that are now synonymous with the character. Among the items Paget chose to emphasize was the detective’s pipe, which he depicted in various styles, including the well-known billiard pipe.
Sidney Paget’s Influence on the Sherlock Holmes Iconography
Sidney Paget began illustrating Sherlock Holmes in The Strand Magazine in the early 1890s, particularly with The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes series, and his artwork became the definitive portrayal of Holmes for many readers. Before Paget's illustrations, Holmes was described in Conan Doyle's writing but lacked a specific, uniform look. Paget’s vision of Holmes introduced readers to Holmes’ long, lean figure, keen eyes, and expressive face—all attributes that matched Holmes’ brilliant but often aloof personality. But beyond just the physical look, Paget included distinct accessories like Holmes’ deerstalker hat and pipe, which became so closely associated with the detective that even today they remain instantly recognizable symbols of Sherlock Holmes.
The Billiard Pipe and Other Types
One of the pipes Paget frequently illustrated with Holmes was the classic billiard pipe. The billiard pipe, with its straight, clean lines and practical design, complemented Holmes’ logical and methodical nature. This pipe style is simple and understated, with a straight stem and bowl positioned at a right angle, making it a popular and practical choice in the Victorian era. The billiard pipe became a signature look for Holmes, offering a functional elegance that matched his character's personality.
Paget’s use of the billiard pipe gave Holmes an air of sophistication and calmness. In several illustrations, Holmes is depicted sitting in his famous armchair, the billiard pipe in hand, as he ponders a complex mystery. This pipe became an essential tool for Holmes, both as a source of comfort and as a ritual that aided his focus and introspection. It’s worth noting that this style of pipe was accessible to the general public, making Holmes seem grounded and relatable, despite his intellectual prowess.
Other Pipe Styles: The Calabash Myth
As shared before, but worth further explanation, it is noteworthy that, while Paget's illustrations primarily show Holmes with the straightforward billiard pipe, other styles, like the curved Calabash pipe, became iconic through adaptations rather than Paget’s work. The Calabash pipe, with its distinct, curved shape, was popularized in stage adaptations and films, such as with William Gillette (the first Sherlock stage actor) as it allowed actors to project their voices clearly while smoking. Though Paget didn’t depict Holmes with a Calabash, it became so associated with Holmes that it is now widely recognized as a “Sherlock Holmes pipe.”
The Churchwarden Pipe and Other Variations
In addition to the billiard, Paget occasionally illustrated Holmes with a long-stemmed Churchwarden pipe. The Churchwarden pipe, with its extended stem, gave Holmes an air of contemplative sophistication, often in scenes where he is deeply engrossed in thought. Its long stem cooled the smoke before it reached the mouth, adding a sensory quality to Holmes’ smoking habit that Paget emphasized through his intricate line work and attention to detail.
The Churchwarden pipe style added visual variety to Paget’s work, showing that Holmes was not confined to one specific pipe style. Instead, the different pipes reflected different aspects of his personality. For example, the Churchwarden’s elegant, elongated look highlighted Holmes’ intellectual side and added a sense of sophistication, while the billiard pipe emphasized his pragmatism.
The Lasting Influence of Paget’s Illustrations
Sidney Paget’s illustrations set the foundation for much of Sherlock Holmes' iconography. His choices in Holmes' appearance—including his pipe—have deeply influenced subsequent portrayals of the detective. By using the simple and elegant billiard pipe, Paget connected Holmes to an image of thoughtful introspection and classic Victorian sophistication. His decision to alternate between the billiard and the Churchwarden pipes added depth to Holmes’ character, subtly suggesting that Holmes could adapt his habits to suit his mood and needs.
Today, Paget’s vision of Sherlock Holmes with a pipe in hand remains one of the most enduring images of the character. Though later adaptations have sometimes added the Calabash pipe to Holmes’ repertoire, the billiard pipe and other styles Paget drew continue to symbolize Holmes’ keen mind, calm demeanor, and meticulous approach to solving mysteries. Thanks to Sidney Paget, the image of Holmes with his pipe endures as one of the most iconic representations of a literary character in modern history.
Conclusion
Sherlock Holmes’ choice of pipes and tobaccos remains one of the most fascinating aspects of his character. From the iconic Calabash and Churchwarden pipes to the robust Black Shag and Latakia tobaccos, each element of his smoking habits contributes to his image as a deeply contemplative detective.
Dr. Watson’s occasional cigars and simpler pipe choices offer a grounding contrast to Holmes’ intensity, deepening their bond as they work side-by-side to solve London’s mysteries. Holmes’ pipe-smoking rituals continue to define him, influencing both detective fiction and popular culture.
For fans of Sherlock Holmes, the sight of him with his pipe is not only a symbol of his brilliance but a reminder of his timeless place in literature.
Comments